|
Graham Greene at the Leproserie
Diary
IT WOULD BE NICE to say that
Graham Greene just appeared one day in Yonda, the leprosy settlement in
the
Equateur Province of the then Belgian Congo where I was the doctor,
stepping
off the gangway of the bishop's riverboat as Querry does in A Burnt-Out
Case.
But Greene did not come unannounced. His visit to Yonda had been
arranged
through a common friend in Brussels.
In his letter to this friend, he had expressed the wish 'for the
purposes of a
book to spend some weeks in a hospital of the Schweitzer kind in Africa, but run by a religious order'. My first
reaction
was mixed: Dr Schweitzer was not highly regarded at the time by health
professionals, and our settlement was very different from the
leproseries that
Greene seemed to be looking for. Yonda was a large village near the
River
Congo, with small brick houses set along avenues bordered by mango
trees; it
housed more than a thousand leprosy patients. There was no segregation
of the
'lepers', a cruel and unnecessary measure meant to prevent the
transmission of
the disease. Leprosy is not particularly contagious, and out of some
100,000
patients at the time in the Congo,
no more than 10 per cent would have been infectious. Patients could go
freely
in and out of the compound; their families lived with them if they
chose to.
There were schools, and children were examined at regular intervals for
the
onset of symptoms, which at an early stage are easy to cure. There were
workshops, plots of land for cultivation and a dozen dugouts (which we
called
'pirogues') on the riverbanks. Some patients used to be fishermen, and
on the
gravel road leading to town one was always coming across patients or
their
relatives pedaling to the market, carrying fish or piles of vegetables
for sale
on the backs of their bicycles. Yonda was aiming to become the
prototype of a
modern institution for the care of leprosy. It didn't seem what Greene
had in
mind for his prospecctive book, and so I did nothing to encourage him
to come,
though I did spend a Sunday preparing a large chart describing a dozen
leproseries in Mrica that seemed to me better suited than Yonda to
accommodate
him.
To tell the truth, I was not
keen to have such a visitor. In spite of Yonda's relative remoteness,
it was on
its way to becoming if not a tourist attraction, at least a showpiece.
I was
also apprehensive that our guest, a famous Catholic writer, might upset
the
delicate balance between myself and the mission. It is not always easy
to be a
mission doctor, especially when one is also a government employee. How
would
the father superior react, cycling non-stop along the avenues chewing
at his
cheroot? Or the father in charge of construction, who in a previous
life had
taught Greek in a provincial Belgian town? Or the brother in charge of
carpentry, who did not speak a word of anything except Frisian, at
times mixed
with some presumably horrendous expletives in Malay, which he had
brought back
from years spent in a Japanese concentration camp during World War Two?
Not to
mention the bishop, described in the Congo Journal as 'a wonderfully
handsome
old man with an 18th-century manner - or perhaps the manner of an
Edwardian
"boulevardier'''? What if this 'pilgrim of the dry season' - the
sarcastic
term used by the colonials to designate passing travelers - did not go
to Mass?
Could he play bridge?
In any event, after a couple
of weeks a letter arrived saying that Greene wanted to come to Yonda.
And then
a second letter arrived: 'The book that I have in mind has a leper
mission
purely as a background and I have no intention, I promise you, of
producing a
roman a clef. .. Nor am looking for any dramatic material. The more
normal and
routine-like that I can make the background the more effective it would
be for
my purpose.' There was a third letter in December: 'I want to see
things as
they are ... I want also to reassure you about the subject of the
novel. The
real subject is a theological and psychological argument which ... I
can't go
into for fear of destroying this still nebulous idea that it should
take place against
the background of an African hospital settlement.'
I went to see the father
superior in order to make the arrangements for the visit. He did not
show
reluctance or surprise. He was quite used to the visitors I brought in,
as well
as to the ones sent occasionally by the colonial administration: a
famous
American ornithologist, an honorary Belgian consul from Sao Paulo, a
Mr. Arnold
from the State Department, the manager of a travelling circus, a
trainee
physiotherapist, a renowned doctor who had crossed the Atlantic on a
raft, a
socialist lady senator, a saxophonist etc. So we prepared for Greene's
visit as
usual, although we forgot to put a coathanger in his room (cassocks are
not
supposed to be hung on coathangers), which apparently embarrassed him.
When Greene arrived nobody
asked any questions. The fathers went on driving trucks, mixing cement,
repairing generators, and went on teaching, preaching and distributing
sweets
to the children. The sisters cycled from the convent to the school and
from the
kitchen to the pharmacy. At the time, the mission was teeming with
frantic
building activity. After years of discussions with the colonial
authorities, it
had been decided to build a hospital to replace the four-room
dispensary which,
since my arrival five years before, had served as consulting-room cum
laboratory and maternity ward. The fathers were feverishly drawing up
blueprints; Edith, my wife, was typing orders. I was ordering
equipment; we
would have electricity. Nobody had much time to devote to our guest.
In the morning Greene would
walk through the meadow to the banks of the Congo, sit in an old
pirogue and
read until the heat became unbearable. He generally had lunch in the
fathers'
house; during the meal the four missionaries would exchange innocent
jokes in
Flemish, bursting into laughter that left him nonplussed. At the end of
the day
he would come to our house for a rest on the veranda and dinner with my
wife
and children. Now and then he joined me in the dispensary and sat on a
chair
between the door and the open window, observing the patients and asking
questions.
Twenty years later, he mentioned in passing in a letter to me the 'fear
I felt
the first few hours with you in the leper colony'. I hadn't noticed.
It's a pity that no one photographed
Greene staring at a patient, as he would: for example, at Imbonga
Bernard, the
man without fingers who had been taught to knit as well as any sister.
He
wrote, too, in his journal of the woman with the palsied eyelids who
could not
close her eyes or even blink. 'The doctor had bought her dark glasses
but she
would not wear them because they were not a medicine - she had trust
only in
drugs.' He added that the patients who had been given orthopaedic shoes
because
their feet were misshapen put them on only on Sundays.
We tried to protect Greene
from people's curiosity. The most obvious nuisances were those who
wanted his
opinion on some manuscript they had in a drawer. The number of people
in a
colonial town looking for a publisher is amazing. They usually showed
up after
five o'clock, 'just to have a beer'. We were well rehearsed. As soon as
a car
was spotted turning off the road and into the long alley of palm trees,
Greene
would rush into the house, jump through our bedroom window, and out
into the forest.
The settlement at Yonda was
beginning to encroach on the equatorial forest, whose edges unfolded
like huge
green cliffs. 'The great trees with their roots like the ribs of ships.
From
the plane they had stood from the green jungle carpet, browning at the
top like
cauliflowers. Their trunks curve a little this way and that, giving the
appearance of reptilian life.' So Greene describes it in Congo Journal.
It
might well have been while running away from these afternoon bores that
he
imagined the flight of Deo Gratias, Querry's boy, into the forest at
night, on
'a rough track which . . . led towards what geographers might have
called the
centre of Africa'.
Visitors to Yonda often
pointed out things I no longer noticed. Greene, by contrast, while a
pleasant
companion when visiting a retired vet in his cocoa plantation, or
strolling
among the giant bamboo canes in a dilapidated botanical garden, kept
his
observations to himself.
There was between us a tacit
pact of mutual reserve; he would have called it a 'duty of reticence'.
He never
asked me about my beliefs, half-beliefs and non-beliefs. The nearest we
came to
discussing religion was on a Sunday driving to attend Mass at the
church in the
African township
of Coq. He said:
'Michel,
I hope it is not for me that you are going to Mass.' I returned the question.
Harassed by
so many people eager to discuss their
religious anxieties with him - there was quite a bunch of them - I
think he
liked my restraint. I also avoided anecdotes that might suggest the
framework
of a novel. The colonial environment, including the missionary world,
is a
breeding ground for all kinds of conflict and entanglement. Gratifying,
I
imagine, to furnish a famous author with a subject.
When I arrived at the
leprosarium as a young doctor, I had a fierce battle with some of the
missionary sisters regarding the care of the patients, a quarrel
between
ancients and moderns. It was the perfect scenario for a Greene novel. I
did not
say a word about it. Twenty-five years later, when we were having lunch
together at Felix's in Antibes,
I raised the subject. He told me that when he had been in Yonda he had
heard a
rum our about the affair, and that he had been grateful to me for not
having
mentioned it, because it would have 'spoiled the whole thing'.
In his Congo Journal he
describes his morning walk through the meadow down to his pirogue:
'Egrets like
patches of arctic snow stand among the small coffee colored cattle. The
huge Congo flowing
with the massive speed of a rush
hour out over the great New
York
bridges. This had not changed since Conrad's day.' As a ship's officer,
Conrad
had manoeuvred the wood-burning stern-wheeler, the Roi des Belges, down
the Congo,
passing
the site of Yonda. (Klein, his travelling companion and the inspiration
for
Kurtz, is buried downstream.) I mentioned Conrad once and immediately
got the
feeling that I had made a faux pas. I was interested to learn, years
later,
that the book he was reading when lying in his pirogue was indeed by
Conrad,
perhaps as a sort of exorcism. The missionaries at Yonda
were very tolerant. Greene wrote about this in his journal soon after
he
arrived:
The husbands are less
inclined to follow their wives than the wives the husbands. The husband
will
set up in his village with another woman, and when the wife finds a
lover to
look after her in the colony, the husband descends demanding justice
and the
return of his 'dot' ... People here are left alone and there are no
moral
inquisitions.
This attitude is evident
throughout the novel. Greene tells the story (a true one) of a man with
no
fingers or toes who brought to be baptised a baby he had fathered by a
woman
crippled from polio. 'There were no questions and no admonitions. The
fathers
were too busy to bother themselves with what the Church considered
sin.' The
fathers really were unconcerned with private lives. In A Burnt-Out
Case,
however, FatherThomas is indignant that the sisters employ a young
teacher who
has 'a baby every year by a different man ... allowing her to teach
with her
cradle in the class. She is pregnant again. What kind of an example is
that?'
The father superior replies: 'We are here to help, father, not to
condemn.'
I believe that Greene was
surprised by what he found in Yonda. Here disease rather than sin took
precedence.
'The priests are more concerned with engineering, electricity,
navigation and
the like, than with the life of man or God,' Greene wrote in Congo
Journal.
Querry 'has come seeking another form of love and is faced with
electric
turbines and problems of building, and he fails to understand the
priests as
much as they fail to understand him'. This might explain why he found
it hard
to write about what he saw in Yonda. 'Never had a novel proved more
recalcitrant,' he later said.
From the Congo,
Greene flew to Douala
in the Cameroons. He wrote us a warm
note of
thanks, and added: 'I forgot to tell you that I went to one other
leproserie
... a mixture of the sentimental and the squalid
... Altogether it made one to
realise all the more strongly what you have accommplished at Yonda.' A
couple
of weeks later, another letter arrived:
I have just received an
account in a local Cameroon
paper of a meeting with me in Douala
and feel
extremely annoyed because I am reported as saying that I preferred the
little
leproserie of Dibamba to those in the Belgian
Congo
- better built, industrialised and less human! I am quoted as saying
that I
would have liked to have passed a fortnight at Dibamba. Needless to say
I said
none of these things.
I wanted to know more about
this place in Dibamba and got a copy of the article. It was described
by the
clerical interviewer as 'un peu de tout, à la francaise'. Greene was
presented
as 'ce géant aux yeux clairs, qui prend la vie comme un collégien en
vacances'.
It was a lyrical elegy, comparing Greene to King Arthur in search of
the Grail,
a high-class Don Giovanni, the bizarre trio of Epicurus, Rabelais and Saint John the
Baptist,
as well as Chesterton, Mao Zedong, Maurice Barres and Victor Hugo. In
this orgy
of comparisons and endorsements, the Dibamba/Yonda contest is an
insignificant
and almost ludicrous footnote. I wrote to reassure him:
Please do not worry about the
Douala article ... It could
well be that the
leproseries in the Congo
are
less compassionate than those in the Cameroon ... Africans are
not
children. We are not here to use them for our self-fulfilment. We are
here to
help the patients into developing their responsibility as human beings
... We
are not looking for gratitude. We want them to get cured, whenever
possible,
and then to forget us afterwards ... It would be good if your Jesuit
journalist
thought about that.
In the novel Greene has
Doctor Colin say: 'A patient can always detect whether he is loved or
whether
it is only his leprosy which is loved. I don't want leprosy loved. I
want it
eliminated.'
I cannot help asking myself
now whether there was a little bit of truth in that Douala interview. Greene later wrote
a
heartfelt review of a book about the leper colony of Lambaréné where
Albert
Schweitzer worked in which he claimed that 'the sentimental hospital
offers something
to the human mind in pain or despair which the scientific may not be
able to
do, and the scientific sometimes fails by reason of its own dogmas.'
Yonda was
an example of good management, but this has its dangers. Could Greene
have
foreseen the drift towards a faceless world of cost-effectiveness,
where cure
is a return on investment, people are human resources, partners are
stakeholders, and patients will soon become clients, disguised behind
statistics?
The fathers and the sisters
made no comment after A Burnt-Out Case was published, just as no
questions had
been asked while Greene was in Yonda. The book, I suppose, joined the
few
romans policiers and the stock of missionary journals on the
chocolate-colored
dresser in the fathers' common room. They probably didn't read it. They
didn't
have time.
Michel Lechat
London
Review of Books 1 August 2007
|