|
Last summer,
Sarah Wendell, an editor of the Web site Smart Bitches, Trashy Books,
posed a
question to her readers: "So what line of dialogue from a romance has
rocked your socks to the point that, long after those socks were lost
in the
dryer, you still remember it?" Jane Austen got a few votes ("You
pierce my soul. I am half agony, half hope"). There were nods to
Georgette
Heyer ("I remember every word you have spoken to me") and Connie
Brockway ("You are my country, Desdemona .... My Egypt. My hot,
harrowing
desert and my cool, verdant Nile, infinitely lovely and unfathomable
and sustaining").
The runaway winner was Nora Roberts-La Nora, the Queen, or, simply, NR.
One
reader nominated "Carnal Innocence," in which the plantation heir
Tucker Longstreet is questioned by an F.B.I. agent about the murder of
an ex-lover
who turns up dead in a local pond:
BURNS: I'm
informed that you and the deceased had a relationship.
TUCKER: What
we had was sex.
Another
chose 'The Heart's Victory," as Lance Matthews, a race-car driver,
walks
in on Cynthia (Foxy) Fox taking a bath:
Foxy: I've
decided to hate you.
LANCE: Oh? Again?
In "Sea
Swept," the first book in Roberts's Chesapeake series, the Quinns are a
trio of foster kids raised as brothers on the Eastern Shore of
Maryland. Their
adoptive father, Ray, dies suddenly, leaving a younger boy, Seth
DeLauter, in
their care. Carn (a peripatetic speedboat racer), Phillip (an
advertising
executive), and Ethan (a commercial fisherman) are forced to move back
into the
house in which they grew up. Together, they drive to the mall to get
some shoes
for Seth:
CAM: You
can't buy decent socks for twenty these days.
ETHAN: You
can if you don't have to have some fancy designer label on them. This
ain't
Paris.
CAM: You
haven't bought decent shoes in ten years. And if you don't pull up that
frigging
seat, I'm going to-
PHILLIP: Cut
it out! Cut it out right now or I swear I'm going to pull over and
knock your
heads together .... I'll dump the bodies in the mall parking lot and
drive to
Mexico. I'll learn how to weave mats and sell them on the beach at
Cozumel. ...
I'll change my name to Raoul, and no one will know I was ever related
to a
bunch of fools.
SETH: Does
he always talk like that?
CAM: Yeah,
mostly. Sometimes he's going to be Pierre and live in a garret in
Paris, but
it's the same thing.
The first
time she read it, Wendell wrote, she laughed so hard that she fell out
of her
beach chair. One reader, a court reporter, confessed that she planned
to
"feign sickness for the next three to six days so I can lay in bed and
reread all my NR yet again."
As a Quinn
brother might say, it had better be one hell of a cold. Roberts, who,
as J. D.
Robb, also writes futuristic police procedurals, has written a hundred
and
eighty-two novels, in addition to short stories and novellas. In a
typical
year, she publishes five "new Noras": two installments of a paperback
original trilogy; two J. D. Robb books; and, each summer, what her
editor,
Leslie Gelbman, refers to as the "big Nora"-a hardcover stand-alone
romance
novel. To keep track of Roberts's output, Amy Berkower, her agent,
maintains a
dry-erase board in her office, along with a running catalogue of
factoids.
Twenty-seven Nora Roberts books are sold every minute. There are enough
Nora
Roberts books in print to fill Giants Stadium four thousand times.
Since 2004,
the cover of each Roberts release has featured a monogram in the
upper-right
corner-the official Nora Roberts seal guarantees that this is a new
work by
Nora Roberts." Her books outnumber her intimates. Only one J. D. Robb
novel
features a dedication-to a friend whose brother is a priest, and who
promised,
in exchange for the mention, to get him to grant Roberts perpetual
absolution.
According to
Publishers Weekly, Roberts wrote three of the ten best-selling
mass-market
paperbacks of 2008: "The Hollow," the second book of the "Sign
of Seven" trilogy (three blood brothers find love and fight a demon);
"High Noon," a reprint of her hardcover romance from 2007 (a hostage
negotiator in Savannah meets a cute sports-bar owner while talking down
a
suicidal bartender); and ''The Pagan Stone," the third book of her
"Sign of Seven" trilogy. "The Hollow" sold 1,912,349
copies, exceeded only by "The Appeal," by John Grisham. Penguin,
Roberts's publisher, shipped six hundred and thirty-seven thousand
copies of
last year's hardback release alone, for a total of more than eight
million
books in 2008. In addition, Roberts sold five and a half million copies
of
backlist titles, and J. D. Robb sold four and a half million books.
Roberts
grosses sixty million dollars a year, Forbes estimated in 2004, more
than Grisham
or Stephen King, who is, incidentally, a Roberts admirer. "Nora Roberts
is
cool," King said, on the jacket blurb for ''Tribute,'' last year's big
Nora. Antoinette Ercolano, a vice-president of trade-book buying at
Barnes
& Noble, said recently that Roberts is the bookseller's top romance
writer.
(The chain's top mystery writer, after Janet Evanovich, is J. D. Robb.)
Diane
Pershing, the president of the Romance Writers of America, told me, on
the
subject of Roberts, "You know that movie 'Amadeus,' where Salieri was
jealous because Mozalt seemed to be taking dictation from God?"
One morning
in December, Roberts was at Vesta, a pizzeria that her older son, Dan,
runs
with his wife in Boonsboro, Maryland. She had driven into town from
nearby
Keedysville, where she lives with her husband, Bruce Wilder. Once she
had taken
off a pair of fleece gloves and a purple sequinned beret, she advanced
a philosophy
of her profession. "You know, writing's creative and all this,
certainly,
but you don't just wander around dreaming," she said. ''That's not what
you're getting paid for." Roberts scoffs at the notion of inspiration,
divine or otherwise. She continued, "People go, 'Oh, you work six or
eight
hours a day, oh my God.' Well, yeah, how many hours do you work?' Well,
yeah,
but .. .' But nothing. I think this is my job. And I think people who
-she
hesitated for a moment-"have more of an artistic bent, they're just not
as
productive, and their writing is probably not any better than mine at
the end
of the day." According to my calculations, it takes Roberts, on
average,
forty-five workdays to write a book.
In March, as
the publishing industry withered, Harlequin, the Canadian romance
house, posted
profits of $18.4 million, up thirty per cent from that time last year.
Romance
is not a genre that suffers slow, or abstracted, authors, and Roberts,
who has
red hair, hooded green eyes, and a pursed half smile, is what used to
be called
a tough broad. Among her friends, she is known as N.F.R.-Nora Fucking
Roberts.
According to the writer Patricia Gaffney, "She sets high professional
and
personal standards for herself and the people around her, and the ones
who
can't live up to them don't always get a lot of sympathy." Roberts is
not
a hugger, or a crier. She has a dirty mouth, a smoker’s voice, and a
closet
full of Armani. Shopping is her main form of self-indulgence -she once
ordered
a Land Rover over the telephone when it was "snowy and crappy" and
her Z had stalled out-but you will not find her in bedroom mules or a
marabou
boa. Her sense of humor can be wicked. “I hope to write the first
romantic
suspense time-travel paranormal thriller set in Mongolia dealing with
Siamese
twins who tragically fall in love with the same woman who may or may
not be
Annie Oakley," she once joked. At Vesta, she said that she has one key
commandment of writing: "Ass in the chair."
Roberts and
Wilder own several businesses in Boonsboro, including Turn the Page, a
bookstore that Wilder, a sweet and lanky
former carpenter, manages. On the day we met, Turn the Page was hosting
a
Roberts signing. There were Nora T-shirts, Nora water bottles, Nora
stadium
cushions, and, as door prizes, some Nora audio-books that Nora had
signed. It
was a Roberts reader's Lourdes. Her devotees amass collections as much
as libraries.
"The Official Nora Roberts Companion," published in 2003, includes a
two-hundred-and-six-page concordance featuring the plotlines and cover
images
from "Affaire Royale" to "Witness in Death." Roberts, who
is fifty-eight, once told USA Today, "I want to die at age one hundred
and
twenty at my keyboard after having great sex."
The signing
began at noon. Roberts, who had dressed up for the event, in a
pumpkin-colored
boiled-wool jacket and olive slacks, was seated at a card table. A
woman in a
police-department sweatshirt approached, holding a copy of 'The Pagan
Stone."
"It was
awesome," she said. "My kids were like, 'Can we have breakfast?' I
was like, 'No eating until I'm done!' "
Roberts took
a swig from a can of Diet Pepsi. Someone passed around a plate of
homemade
oatmeal cookies. Listening to the give-and-take between Roberts and her
fans
was like eavesdropping on the collective unconscious of American women:
bichons
frises, migraines, Christmas shopping, marital problems.
A woman in
her twenties handed Roberts a copy of "Morrigan's Cross," from 2006.
"I usually read these as soon as they come out, but I have a
six-month-old,"
she said.
An older
woman chimed in, "You've got to learn to rock him and read."
''Yes, or
read to him," Roberts said.
"'Cause they really can't understand those
parts."
"My
five didn't!" the older woman said.
A girl
approached carrying a souvenir tote bag. "Everybody's reading Nora,"
it said.
'J.D. is
offended, but I'm not," Roberts said. She added, in a stage whisper,
"She's a bitch, anyway."
"Does
your hand hurt from all that writing?" someone asked, as Roberts,
wearing
a Celtic thumb ring (she also has a Celtic tattoo on her ankle),
scrawled her
autograph.
Roberts
replied, "I'm going to treat it with alcohol internally later."
Smart-alecks
make bad pupils but excellent students of human nature:
Roberts is
good at what she does not only because she is prolific but also because
she can
write zingy dialogue and portray scrappy but sincere characters. She is
known
for her particularly believable heroes-according to Wendell, "100% real
dudes." Her female characters frequently possess an entrepreneurial
streak,
and they are more independent than many of their peers, and certainly
their
predecessors, even if some among them still have a propensity for
crumpling
like tissues at the sight of bodily fluids. " 'Oh. Oh my,' was all she
managed before her eyes rolled back," Roberts writes, of Faith Lavelle,
who, in "Carolina Moon," has agreed to help the bachelor veterinarian
Wade Mooney perform an operation on an injured sheepdog. Roberts's
colloquial
style can be inelegant, but it deflates the more vaporous of her
scenes-Wade
revives Faith, and, in a few sentences, they are back to talking about
"dog poop."
A
self-taught writer, and an irreverent one, Roberts was not, at first,
an easy
sell. Amy Berkower said, "I remember Nancy"-Nancy Jackson, the editor
who acquired Roberts's first novel, in 1980-"standing on her head to
get
Nora's books because they didn't follow the formula as strictly as
others." In violation of Lubbock's Law, a genre convention stating
that,
for reasons of reader identification, romances should be written from
only the
heroine's point of view, Roberts sometimes adopted the hero's
perspective. As
she and her peers evolved, so did the genre, away from the so-called
"fight 'em and fuck 'em" romances of the seventies toward a more
contemporary, American style that portrayed increasingly, if not
entirely,
companionate relationships. "The classic British romances focused on
the
war between the sexes," Isabel Swift, who edited Roberts for years at
Harlequin, said. 'With Nora, it was more of a challenge than a real
battle of
wills." Reading a Roberts novel is like watching a game of tennis
between
two very good players: it is not so much the outcome of the match but
the back-and-forth
between commensurate opponents that elicits the spectator's pleasure.
Robert
has never depicted a male virgin- least not that she can remember-or an
abortion, but Parker Brown, the heroine of "Happy Ever After," which
will come out next year, is a wedding planner, "of the Connecticut
Browns," and her love interest is a mechanic.
Roberts's
predominance is a feat of marketing as much as of style. At one point,
Roberts
had delivered a trilogy to Penguin, the installments of which were
scheduled to
run a year apart. "I went nuts," Berkower recalled. "They said
they didn't want to overexpose Nora. And I said, Well, she's not Mickey
Mouse
yet.' " The parties compromised on a book every six months, a
publishing
schedule that they have adhered to since. Berkower and Roberts
conceived of J.
D. Robb in 1995, as a way to capitalize upon Roberts's rate of
production. The
effect of the ploy was not only to turn up the pace of the treadmill
for the
publishing industry but also to conjoin the genres of romance and
crime, along
with their readerships. John Lennard, a professor of literature at the
University
of the West Indies, wrote, in an essay on Roberts, "Roberts has in some
ways done for Romance what the hyper-celebrity of Harry Potter has done
for
Children's Literature, making it acceptable fare for reading adults in
general." To project mainstream appeal, Roberts's books typically
feature
her name, in big letters, and some sort of inanimate, totemic object
(cattails,
a lighthouse, a shrimp trawler), rather than what she has called
"nursing
mother" covers-"when she's falling out of her dress, and he has his
mouth on her tit."
The Times
Book Review-Roberts has spent more than seven hundred weeks on the
paper's
best-seller list-has reviewed her once. "They're keeping the lights on
late for the promise of heaving bosoms and consciousness-altering
orgasms,"
a reviewer wrote of "Northern Lights," a 2004 romantic thriller set
in the Alaskan bush. Roberts is as uninterested in the literary
establishment
as she is unloved by it. "She didn't go to college, much less major in
English, or take courses at the Iowa Writers' Workshop or Bread Loaf,"
Patricia Gaffney told me. "She's indifferent to what critics say are
the
rules for proper fiction writing."
Toward the
end of the signing, a woman said, "Do you know, Nora, that my goal is
to
read every book you've ever written?"
'Well, if
I've written them, you can read them," Roberts replied. "It takes me
longer."
Every romance requires two elements: a love story and a happy
ending. "Pamela; or, Virtue Rewarded," Samuel Richardson's tale of a
naive servant girl who is courted by her employer, Mr. B., is
considered by
many scholars to be the first romance novel. Published in 1740, it was
an
instant best-seller, spawning merchandise (teacups, fans) and, as
romance novels
always have, highbrow derision (in Henry Fielding's "Shamela," the
heroine is a wily strumpet who marries Booby for his money). Pamela
Regis, a
professor of English at McDaniel College, in her book "A Natural
History
of the Romance Novel," charts the course of the genre from Richardson
to
Austen to Bronte to Forster. E. M. Hull's "The Sheik"-the tale of an
aristocratic Englishwoman who, travelling through the Algerian desert,
is captured
and raped by a libidinous chieftain, and, despite "the sickening reek
of
his clothes," eventually falls in love with him-was published in 1919.
The
"ur-romance novel of the twentieth century," according to Regis, it
marked the emergence of the swashbuckling tale of high sexual adventure
against
an exotic backdrop as an "enormously popular" form.
By the
nineteen-fifties, the English house Mills & Boon was publishing
what would
evolve into category romances-short, branded series books, later sold
in
grocery stores and at newsstands and by subscription. Led by such
bodice-rippers
as Kathleen E. Woodiwiss's "The Flame and the Flower" and Rosemary
Rogers's "Sweet Savage Love," romance experienced a boom, in
popularity and in profits, beginning in the seventies. In 1971,
Harlequin
bought Mills & Boon. The Romance Writers of America issued its
first RITA
awards in 1981. Roberts has won nineteen of them, and has been inducted
into
the R.W.A. Hall of Fame three times. Regis writes, "The five writers
who
belong in any list of canonical twentieth-century romance writers are
Georgette
Heyer, Mary Stewart, Janet Dailey before her self-admitted plagiarism,
Jayne
Ann Krentz, and Nora Roberts." Roberts is perhaps doubly canonical:
Dailey, with whom Roberts was friendly, plagiarized from a number of
her books,
an experience that Roberts has likened to "mind rape." (Roberts sued
for copyright infringement in 1997, and the case was settled out of
court.)
Romance was,
in a sense, user-generated content before user-generated content
existed-from
the outset, its publishers assumed that readers would want to write,
providing
tip sheets for prospective authors and accepting their manuscripts over
the
transom. The opening spread of Roberts's first book, "Irish
Thoroughbred" (1981), featured this message from the publisher: "Dear
Reader ... you play an important part in our future plans for
Silhouette
Romances. We welcome any suggestions or comments on our books and I
invite you
to write to us at the address below." Early in her career, Roberts
embarked on a grassroots promotion tour. At a nursing home, a man with
a walker
shuffled up to the meeting room and read a sign on the door. "Nora
Roberts?" he said, disgustedly. "I thought it was Oral Roberts."
Loyalty
means much to Roberts - Berkower has been her agent for her entire
career-and
it endears her greatly to the romance community that, even after her
crossover
success, she continued, until failing to come to terms with Harlequin,
in 2005,
to write category romances. For twenty-eight years, she has attended
the R.W.A.
convention. Every year, on a Sunday night, she and the writer Ruth Ryan
Langan
throw a pajama party. 'We just giggle and kick off our shoes," Langan
said. "I think last year, in San Francisco, we ordered popcorn and
champagt1~." Roberts does impressions. According to the writer Mary Kay
McComas, "She is a magnificent Scottish Highlander-except that they
sometimes sound exactly like her Ohio River riffraff from a Western
novel."
When the
Internet took off, Roberts, who loathes flying, seized upon it as a way
to
interact with her readers. Amy Berkower recalled, "I remember I was on
vacation in Costa Rica, and I ran into a guy who was the editorial
director of
AOL at the time. He said, 'I wish other authors were more like Nora.'
And I
said, Why?' He said, Well, apparently, she goes into chat rooms on,
like, New
Year's Eve.'''
In 1997, a
group of Roberts fans- Noraholics-established a site called ADWOFF, in
honor of
a comment that Roberts had made on an AOL message board:
Barb, how
can one live without French fries. Not well, I say. In fact, I've been
known to
say a day without fries is like a day without an orgasm.
Roberts
mastered viral marketing early. Sue Noyes, who runs ADWOFF, was turned
on to
Nora by Nora. "I was looking for a new author, and so I went on AOL and
said, 'Convince me, people, why you think I should read Nora Roberts
instead of
Patricia Cornwell,' " Noyes, a grocery-store manager in Scranton,
recalled. "Nora came in and said, Well, if you give me a try, let me
know
what you think.' "
ADWOFF
maintains a first-generation feel. Its participants go by names like
Puppy
Princess of Peanut Butter and Birthdays, and Countess Coffee of the
Caffeinated
Canines. On one message board, "Stooooopid Questions!," readers can
quiz Roberts about whatever they please: "Hi, Nora! This is really
random,
but do you like salmon?" (A. "Actually, salmon is my least favorite
of the fishies"), "Have you ever dropped anything important or of
value in the toilet?" (A. ''I'm a big believer in not just keeping the
seat down, but keeping the lid down for just that reason"), "Nora, in
the grand scheme of things, what is better ... a glue stick or a glue
gun?" (A. "A glue stick's more portable, right?"). Roberts has
been asked, at least twice, if she likes "Riverdance," and why cargo
is called cargo if it's sent by ship.
Roberts's
persona is nurturing-for hiccups, "Drink water out of a clear glass,
watching your finger while you draw a circle around the bottom as you
drink"; for an ice pack, use frozen peas-but never vulnerable. Her
readers
crave her attention more than she craves theirs, and the power
differential,
which has widened over the years, affords the occasional awkward
moment.
"As there always seems to be at least one photojournalist in every
family,
is BW ... the one who currently takes photos at every family gathering
[and]
maintains them in photo or scrap books?" Ocean-devotion wrote, of Bruce
Wilder. "BW’s usually too busy at gatherings to take too many photos.
Nobody around here scrapbooks," Roberts wrote back.
Sentimentality
cloaked in snappiness-whether in imitation of Roberts or by proximity
to her-is
the site's prevailing register. Roberts's witticisms can sometimes seem
facile,
as if she were reading from a needlepoint pillow. "And the day Jesse
Cooke, ex-Marine, let a woman outwit him was the day they'd eat cherry
Popsicles in hell," she writes, in "Montana Sky." But her fans,
tellers of riddles and doers of Sudoku, value cleverness. "If every
clock
in the house is set to a different time, what time is it?" one reader
inquired.
Roberts's response: "Hopefully, it's Happy Hour Time."
When Roberts writes a book, she assembles a community piece
by piece, a train-set village of her own invention. In "Tribute,"
Cilla McGowan, a former child star, moves from Los Angeles to the
Shenandoah
Valley, to renovate a farmhouse that belonged to her grandmother.
Roberts
narrates Cilla's seduction-by the place, and by Ford Sawyer, a graphic
novelist
who lives across the road-in a plainspoken but moving aria on the joys
of rural
living: "In this world, Cilla discovered, people ate homemade lasagna
and
apple cobbler, and treated a meal as food rather than a performance.
And a
guest or family ... was given a plate of each covered in tinfoil to
take home
for leftovers. If the guest/family was driving, she was offered a
single glass
of wine with dinner, then plied with coffee afterward."
Roberts
would have made a keen satirist, were she not without condescension, or
cruelty. In "Montana Sky," she pokes fun at the pace of life on a
cattle ranch:
"Ham
blew out smoke, watched it drift to the ceiling. Willa imagined cities
being
built, leveled, new stars being born, novas." She does great busybodies
and wacky relations. In "Carolina Moon," Tory Bodeen, back in
Progress, South Carolina, after many years, steps into the local
real-estate
office (downtown, near the Flower Basket, Hair Today, and Rollins Paint
&
Hardware) and runs into Lissy Harlowe, the most popular girl from high
school.
"Now, you just tell me everything you've been up to," Lissy says.
Rosie Sikes
LaRue Decater Smith is the aunt of the man Tory ends up falling in love
with:
"She wore a wig, at least Tory assumed it was a wig, of platinum blond,
a
flowing floor-length dress striped like a red-and-white awning, and
enough
jewelry to topple a lesser woman." Rosie, a compulsive shopper, arrives
at
the gift shop that Tory has just opened:
"Now
what the blue hell is this thing?"
She picked
up a polished wooden stand with a hole in it.
"It's a
wine rest."
"Don't
that beat all? Why anybody'd want to give a decent bottle of wine time
to rest
is beyond me. Wrap me up two of those. Lucy Talbott!"
Roberts's
characters fill up their tanks at the Qwik Mart, buy Nutter Butters and
Little
Debbies, and bitch about the "goddamn go-coffee from Sheetz." They
eat bagels while battling the forces of evil. Their parents, and often
their
grandparents, are present in the narrative. Hers are not Carrie
Bradshaw
fantasies.
Born Eleanor
Marie Robertson in Silver Spring, Maryland, in 1950, Roberts writes
what she
knows, in a general sense-hardworking people who would kill for their
kids but
who otherwise don't take themselves too seriously. Her father, Bernard,
was a
stagehand and projectionist who eventually opened a lighting business.
Her
mother, Eleanor, was a homemaker and later a partner in the business.
They met
as teen-agers in northeastern Washington, D.C., after Eleanor had just
broken
up with one of Bernard's brothers, and their relationship figures
prominently
in Roberts's mythology of romantic love. "My father always walked with
his
hands in his back pockets, and he's kind of swaggering and he says to
his
brother, 'Leave her alone.' My mother asked her mother if she could go
out with
him. And my grandmother said, 'You mean Bessie's bad Bernie?'" They
were
married, Roberts mentions frequently, for sixty-three years.
Roberts was
the youngest of five children, and the only girl. The Robertsons were
traditional Irish Catholics. (Roberts, who is interested in Wicca and
other
spiritual practices, calls herself "very
lapsed.") Nora was expected to make her brothers' beds. Her father
often
took her with him to the movie theatre. "I remember this double
feature--I
sat all day in the theatre and it was 'Peter Pan' and 'The King and I,'
"
she recalled. "When they did the 'Shall We Dance?' number, I was just
swept away. Later, I realized there's such restrained sexuality in that
dance,
but as a child I just knew there was something really important and
exciting
going on, besides the music." Roberts attended an all-girl parochial
school until ninth grade, when a nun named Sister Alice Maureen became
Mother
Superior. She made participation mandatory in a game called Paul
Revere, in
which each girl had to carry one of her classmates on her back and run
the
length of the gym. "I was this bone-skinny runt, and I could not do
it," Roberts recalled. "My mother finally let me go to Blair-'Boys!'
"
At
Montgomery Blair High School, Roberts dated a classmate named Ronnald
Aufdem-Brinke, whom she married upon graduation, at the age of
seventeen. The
couple settled in Keedysville, in an out-of-the-way ranch house in
which
Roberts continues to live. In 1972, Dan was born. Three years later,
another
son, Jason, arrived. Aufdem-Brinke worked for a sheet-metal
manufacturer;
Roberts was briefly a legal secretary, before quitting to stay home.
She refers
to those years as her "Earth Mother" period. "I baked bread,
canned, sewed, macramed, embroidered, grew vegetables," she once told
an
interviewer. "I was obviously looking for a creative outlet."
In February
of 1979, a now legendary snowstorm hit. Roberts, trapped in the house
"with a three- and a six-year-old ... and a dwindling supply of
chocolate,"
picked up a legal pad and scratched out her first manuscript. It
featured a
Spanish hero and a heroine with a sprained ankle, and was, Roberts
asserted
later, "simply dreadful." Roberts kept writing. In 1980, Silhouette
accepted "Irish Thoroughbred," which was pretty dreadful, too
("You impudent little wench!" "You great thundering
blackguard!"), but possessed flashes of the spiritedness and humor that
would define her success.
In Boonsboro, which is known for it cantaloupes, Roberts is a
prominent but elusive citizen. She contributes handsomely to local
causes (the
fire department, the library) but sometimes, she told me, does not
leave her
house for three weeks. In the past year, she has been more visible than
usual, transforming a dilapidated historic building on the town's main
square
into a small boutique hotel called Inn BoonsBoro. Robelts owns
buildings on
three of the four corners in the middle of town, which some locals
refer to as Nora
Square. 'We're just so proud to say we have Nora in Boonsboro," Debra
Smith,
the town manager, told me.
The inn, which opened earlier this year, has seven themed
rooms, all dedicated to pairs of literary lovers. There is
heather-scented hand
lotion in the Jane and Rochester Room. The Eve and Roarke Room-named
for the
protagonists of the J. D. Robb books-is furnished with a mod orange
chair. On
the morning of February 22,2008, as the renovation neared completion, a
liquid-propane tank ignited and set fire to the inn and several
adjacent
buildings. By nightfall, only the original masonry remained. Within
days,
Roberts had announced that I she would
rebuild. The saga of the inn played out like something from a Nora
Roberts
novel about tragedy, pettiness, grace, and, ultimately, resilience in a
small
town. ("I was just reading about the fire in Boonsboro-Nora Roberts,
Nora
Roberts, Nora Roberts," an anonymous reader wrote to the Hagerstown
Herald-Mail.) "Blue Smoke," the big Nora from 2005, contains an
eerily prescient passage, in which the heroine, Reena Hale, on the day
she gets
her first period, watches the family pizzeria go up in flames: "She
would
never forget it, not for all of her life, standing with her family
while
Sirico's burned .... She could feel it inside her belly, the fire, like
the
cramping. The wonder and horror, the awful beauty of it, pulsed there."
“Blue
Smoke" takes place in Baltimore. Roberts's readers identify not only
with
her settings but also with her protagonists-fundamentally kind,
optimistic
people who talk about cars ("You pop the clutch and drive around at
ninety, you're going to be stacking up tickets like cordwood"), wear
grungy clothes ("Her own Arctic-blue eyes [were] shaded by the bill of
a Rock the House ball cap"), and,
even with a serial killer on the loose, think such positive thoughts as
"A
friendly screen door should squeak, and it should squeal." In her
choice
of milieu, if nothing else, Roberts is the Raymond Carver of romance.
Her
characters thirst for cold beers on the porch, not Daiquiris by the
pool.
Occasionally, she can make you yearn for Tahiti-one of the Quinn
brothers, in
"Sea Swept," fantasizes about a "hot-looking C.P.A"
The idea that readers turn to romance to escape their drab,
loveless lives is, in Roberts's opinion, a canard. Her view is borne
out by the
market: according to the R.W.A., romance generated nearly $1.4 billion
in sales
in 2007, more than science fiction and fantasy combined (seven hundred
million
dollars), mystery (six hundred and fifty million), or literary fiction
(four
hundred and sixty-six million). Of people who read books, one in five
read a
romance. The engine of the genre, according to Roberts, is not escapism
but
identification. "For the kind of books I write, character is key,"
she said. "Character is plot. Make them accessible to the reader. They
may
be a billionaire or they may be a half demon or they may be a gym
teacher, but
something about them has to relate so the reader can say, 'I understand
them.'
" Like campfire stories, Roberts's books rely on verve and familiarity
rather
than on any particular polish or originality. One of Roberts's editors
once received
some feedback from a romance readers' focus group: "My life is
'Moby-Dick.' I don't need to read it."
At dinner with Roberts and Wilder one night, I mentioned a
scene in her novel "Birthright," in which the heroine, Callie
Dunbrook, receives a coffee-table book about Pompeii from a man who
mayor may
not be her father, who confesses to once having made the mistake of
selecting
an automotive accessory as an anniversary gift for his wife.
"You'll never live it down," Roberts said to
Wilder, who was engrossed in a large platter of eggplant parmigiana.
She turned to me. "He doesn't even know what I'm talking
about!"
Roberts continued, "First Christmas! What did you give
me our first Christmas?"
"I don't remember," Wilder replied.
"I do. Car mats."
Many
romances begin with a "cute meet," in which the hero and the heroine
are introduced to each other in some novel manner. Nora Roberts met
Bruce
Wilder in 1983, when he came to her house to build some bookshelves.
Newly
divorced, she was not looking for a relationship. "'Men? I spit on
men,'
" Roberts recalled, of her mind-set. When Wilder called to ask her over
for dinner, she was surprised. "I hadn't dated since high school, since
I
got married straight out," she said. "But I thought, Well, if he was
an axe murderer or a serial rapist, I've been here alone with him at
the house,
so I'd already be dead." Wilder cooked spaghetti. His house was tidy.
Roberts likes to say she married him so that she didn't have to pay for
the
bookshelves.
Roberts calls her house the Fortress of Solitude. Over the
years, she has made additions, and it is a rambling, log-cabinish
affair, with
an indoor pool and a porch painted turquoise. The walls are decorated
with
postcards from Galway and with lace crocheted by Roberts's mother. A
pub-like
basement features two pinball machines, a pachinko game, and a "dirty
dartboard" ("Touch with Ice," "Kiss My Ear"). In the
study, near a pair of leather recliners, is a large portrait depicting
Bruce
and Nora as Rick and Ilsa from "Casablanca." Dan, Roberts's son, and
his family live a few houses down. When he and Jason were young, and
Roberts
went on book tours, a set of neighbor triplets, one of whom is now
Boonsboro's
mail carrier, would babysit. One day in February, Roberts, explaining
why she
lives where she does, said, "There's a word in Irish-comhar-which
in the vernacular of the rural West counties means a
sense of community and neighbor helping neighbor." As we pulled to the
end
of the long gravel drive leading up to the house, a statue of Merlin
stood
sentry at her back door. "It's burlwood chain-saw art," Roberts said.
"I saw him in California, and I had him shipped out. He's too cool."
Initially,
Roberts wrote wherever she could: in the car-pool line, at the
dentist's
office. As her career took off, she began to establish boundaries:
"Don't
bother me unless it's blood or fire. And, as they grew more
responsible,
arterial blood and active fire." At the end of the day, she would pay
the
kids ten cents a page to feed paper into her Wang word processor. Now
she works
at home, in a third-floor office overlooking acres of oaks, poplars,
and tulip
trees. A mobile in the shape of a fire-breathing dragon hangs from a
skylight.
Her desk is covered in bobble-heads and tchotchkes: Alfred E. Neuman,
Mulder
and Scully, Spike from "Buffy the Vampire Slayer," a pop-up nun.
Routine is
vital to Roberts. Unlike most people who come into a great deal of
money, she
has used hers to maintain her life, rather than to refashion it. (Her
main
concession to her income, besides the shopping, is to charter a private
jet
when she travels.) On a typical day, she gets up at around six, works
out in
the basement, and is sitting down at her computer by eight o'clock. She
limbers
up with a game of Gem Drop or Jewel Quest Solitaire, checks the blogs,
and
writes for six to eight hours, fuelling herself with Winston Filter
100s,
Cheez-Its, and Diet Pepsi from a litre bottle. Around five o'clock each
afternoon, she goes downstairs to prepare dinner. For years, people
have been
telling her to hire a cook. She has no assistant or research aide. 'Why
would
you want people in your house?" she said. "Then you have to talk to
them." Every January, she and Wilder go to a spa in the Pennsylvania
hills. Ruth Ryan Langan and her husband usually visit in November.
Langan said,
"On our first night, Nora usually has pasta with red sauce and a green
salad with shredded carrots."
Roberts may
be the most intuitive writer since Noel (Hot Lead) Loomis, who wrote
several
dozen Westerns straight onto a Linotype machine he kept in his house.
She
doesn't keep bios on her characters. She never makes an outline, and
she does
most of her research on Google. Before she wrote "Montana Sky," her
editor suggested that she go to Montana. 'Why would I want to go to
Montana?"
Roberts said. To start, Roberts has said, “I’ll vomit out the first
draft." She typically goes through twice more and sends "the best
book I can write at that time" to her editor. Roberts hates it when
people
ask her where she gets her ideas. 'It's not like I go out, pluck them
off the
Idea Bush or pick up a few at the Idea Store," she has said. She told
me
she has never quit on a manuscript: '1 will beat it. I will wrestle it
to the
ground. It will not defeat me." (She has, however, disowned one book:
"Promise Me Tomorrow," a 1984 novel with an unhappy ending that Roberts
says "was full of clichés," and is now for sale for a hundred dollars
on Amazon.) The months following the discovery of Janet Dailey's
plagiarism
were the only time in her career that she has felt blocked. Roberts is
still
heated about it. "Don't push an Irishwoman into a corner," Roberts
told me. "Then she's going to come out, and she's going to have your
blood
in her throat."
Roberts's
influences are myriad and mostly popular. She assesses books and movies
summarily, like an emperor deciding the fate of a gladiator. She likes
"Catch-22"
(so many layers), “The Stand” ('Just a
precious jewel'), Robert Parker, Baz Luhrmann's "Australia," and
Larry McMurtry ("until the sad parts"). She has not seen or read
"Revolutionary Road," but she dislikes it anyway ("I don't want
to be brought down like that"). She is proud of her knowledge of pop
culture and is impatient with eggheads. "Copy-editors? You want me to
start on copy-eds?" she wrote, on a Web site. "The ones who neglect
to correct lie to lay, then tell me Suellen isn't a character from Gone
With
the Wind, but from the TV show Dallas?" One day, as we were talking, I
mentioned, guiltily, that I never read Proust. "I don't particularly
want
to," Roberts said. "I do not feel obliged in my reading. I read to be
entertained and to relax, and to go into another world, not because
it's good
for me." She paused, nostrils flared, and said, "I don't eat
broccoli, either."
Most writers
have worked out the kinks in their writing by the time they are
published, but
in romance many writers develop on the job. Roberts's writing, by her
own
estimation, has improved markedly since her early novels, which
featured a lot
of passive constructions and thesaurus words. Compared with Nora
Roberts, J. D.
Robb is slightly more staccato and noirish, but Roberts says that the
voices
are essentially the same. In both incarnations, she is spare, catchy,
and
impressionistic. Her sentences are often clipped, and she has a habit
of turning
adjectives and nouns into verbs ("two canine forms bulleted out" the
door). Her figurative language can be clever ("Dobby's face reminded
Cilia
of a piece of thin brown paper that had been balled tight, then
carelessly
smoothed out") or it can be clumsy ("They meshed like butter on
popcorn, both lively and entertaining").
Almost
everyone I spoke with praised Roberts's storytelling, her incantatory
ability
to engage the reader. "Storytelling" also suggests a
quasi-extemporaneous quality, the privileging of the thrust of a
narrative over
its details, and while Roberts's narratives have momentum, they are not
always painstakingly
crafted. In "The Pagan Stone," she interrupts what is supposed to be
a climactic and scary fight scene with a digression involving the B-52s
song
"Love Shack." It might be a funny set piece, with some of the
body-dropping camp of the James Bond movies, if we weren't supposed to
take the
song seriously, as a "battle cry' that" as so in-your-face, so
utterly and humanly defiant." Her plotting can be erratic. In
'Tribute," Matt and Josie's son is called Sam on page 274. By page 392,
his name has become Ethan. The head medical examiner's name is Morse in
some of
the J. D. Robb books; in others, it is Morris. To immediately justify a
character's
psychology, Roberts may supply him or her with a flimsy backstory. In
"Glory
in Death," the police psychologist Dr. Charlotte Mira says that, as a
child, she was raped by her stepfather-who, in ''Purity in Death," is
semi-retired and living in Connecticut. "It's sort of embarrassing,"
Roberts told me, of her occasional bloopers. "You just feel like an
idiot."
Another
pitfall, when you've written almost two hundred books, is
repetitiveness.
"I feel like I've met Cilia in other Nora
books," a reader wrote in a generally positive review of 'Tribute" on
ADWOFF. "I have nothing against self assured not prissy, comfy, but 'I
spruce up nice' girls [but] the female characters have just been very
similar." The spunky-heroine voice that Roberts favors is winning, but
it
can seem like a fallback. Would a twenty-four-year-old say, "I thought
he
waited for you at the side door every night, then walked you back at
dawn
because you were holding a secret canasta tournament"? At other times,
her
characters, grousing about "sons of bitches" and vowing to
"welsh on" their enemies, seem to hail from the Nixon era.
"You
cannot write with the reader over your shoulder," Roberts told me. But
she
is keenly attuned to the demands of the market. At Harlequin's request
for a
"Batman-type character," she once created a hero who could walk
through walls. The producer Peter Guber has adapted a number of
Roberts' s
books into Lifetime movies, four of which aired on Saturday nights this
spring.
(New York rated the ad campaign, a series of pastel- heavy posters that
colonized the city's subways and buses, as "lowbrow" and
"despicable," but the movies are Lifetime's most-watched programs
this year.) "She's not a pain in the ass," Guber told me. "You
have to listen to her, but, at the same time, she was completely like,
'You
want to blend those two secondary characters together? Great. Not a
problem.'" Roberts's readers value consistency, not experimentation or
risk-taking. "Except for some of the early category romances, I really
haven't found a bad Nora read," Sue Noyes, of ADWOFF, said. It would be
nice if every book was Roberts's dream house, but she will build to
spec.
Roberts has
a riff about the sort of romance novel that was popular at the
beginning of her
career:
He was often
a Greek tycoon; she was often orphaned and raised by an aunt. She's on
her way
to a new job, working for the richest man in the free world. In the
airport,
she's rushing through with her battered suitcase. She runs into this
man and
the suitcase falls open, revealing a pitiful wardrobe-it's all neat and
well-mended but sad. And he calls her a clumsy fool and helps her stuff
her
clothes back into the suitcase and storms off, and the next day she
goes into
the offices of the richest man in the free world and who should be
there but
the man she ran into in the airport?
Its class
and the sexual dynamics have progressed, but romance, which Roberts has
said
holds a "watery mirror" up to its times, is still a genre. Pamela
Regis identified its eight essential elements, which Sarah Wendell and
Candy
Tan, in their new book "Beyond Heaving Bosoms: The Smart Bitches' Guide
to
Romance Novels," have condensed to four: "Boy meets girl. Holy crap,
shit happens! Eventually, the boy gets the girl back. They live Happily
Ever
After." (In a 1981 survey, the literature professor Jannice A. Radway
found that the romance readers in her sample group considered the
depiction of
rape only slightly less objectionable than a sad ending.) Chapter 19 of
“Writing a Romance Novel for
Dummies"
offers a list of familiar plot elements: Marriage of Convenience,
Stranded with
a Stranger, Runaway Bride, Woman in Jeopardy, Back from the Dead,
Mistaken
Identity, Secret Baby, Reunion Romance, the Dad Next Door. (Roberts's
rule of
thumb: "one cliché per story.") "Heroes from Germany,
Scandinavia, and the former Soviet Union and its current descendant
states have
all proven a difficult sell," it warns. According to industry legend, a
book tanked when its publisher omitted from its cover the single light
that
customarily shines from an upper window of a grays-tone castle.
Even the
sexual content of romance novels is highly codified. The Arabesque
Romance
guidelines "strongly discourage having the characters live together as
a
couple," although "some story lines do allow for premarital
conception, as long as the couple eventually marries." In the Steeple
Hill
Love Inspired line, authors should "avoid any mention of nudity."
(The characters should also be North American, and they should not take
"the Lord's name in vain" or use "euphemisms for
curses"-"heck, darn, gosh.") The Black Lace erotic-fiction line,
published in the U.K., allows for clitoral piercings but "no
animals, lasting physical damage, parent/child incest or misery."
There is a
kitchen-table quality to sex in romance novels which distinguishes them
from
pornography. Gay critics have pointed out that you could substitute
"she" for every "he" in many sex scenes, and they would
still work. "She smelled like the woods, he thought," Roberts writes,
in "The Pagan Stone." "Autumn woods. Nothing fragile and pastel
like spring, but rich and vivid, with just a hint of smoke." Probably
no
man has ever thought this, but it's effective stuff. In the same way
that women
dress for other women, romance novels stem from, and speak to, the
female
imagination. Fine, strapping fellows as the men are, they might not
always be
recognizable to their human counterparts.
In Roberts's
early books, the sex could be rough and spastic. Travis Grant says to
Adelia
Cunnane in "Irish Thoroughbred," "You'll come to Kentucky
because it suits me to have you there, and I'm accustomed to having
what suits
me." Roberts continues:
His smile
spread in a rapid change of mood as her head snapped up with fresh
anger. His
hands claimed her waist, then trailed slowly upward, resting on the
sides of
her firm young breasts as her anger faded into confusion .... Her lips
parted,
but she found no strength to protest against the unfamiliar intimacy
.... She
felt herself rising from the ground, and her hands went to his
shoulders
automatically to compensate for the loss of gravity.
Later, Adelia's
hand finds its way to Travis's shoulder "of its own accord." One day,
I brought up Roberts's old habit of inventing mechanical justifications
for female
participation in sex. "Oh, yes-'As if by its own volition, her hand
stroked his cheek,'" Roberts said, smiling. "It was a learning
process."
Many romance
authors hate talking about their sex scenes as much as their fans look
forward
to reading them, but Roberts is not prickly about the subject. "Sex is
important
in the books because, without it, it would be like eating a rice cake
instead
of a cupcake," she told me. She is amused by the frequent assumption
that
her own life is unusually amorous. ("Did people ever ask Agatha
Christie
if she was homicidal?") In reality, she is a deeply pragmatic romantic.
In
an essay included in "The Official Nora Roberts Companion," she
admitted that her idea of true passion was the kiss that AI Gore
planted on
Tipper during the
Democratic Convention in 2000. ''You go, Al," she wrote.
Still,
Agatha Christie, over the years, probably picked up on a few things
about
forensics. I asked Roberts how far she would go in writing sex scenes.
''I'm
not going to write about stuff that you might read about in some
erotica-you
know, blood play," she said. "And I'm probably not going to do S
&M. I'm not going to do any harsh sex that involves pain." Whether
or
not her characters use condoms depends, she said, on the circumstances:
"I'm not a public-service announcement. I'm not going to screw up the
mood
just so I can be politically correct." She continued, "My favorite
use of condoms was in 'Montana Sky,' when Tess goes to seduce Nate at
his desk
and he's kind of like, ‘Well, you know, I'm not prepared,' and she
pulls out
like twenty of them, and he doesn't know whether to be flattered or
afraid." When Roberts doesn't mention birth control, she said, it is an
artistic omission, and the reader can assume that the characters took
care of
it.
The hallmark
of Roberts's sex scenes is narrative continuity-the hero and the
heroine sleep
together, and they don't suddenly turn into wildly different people.
"It's
not deliberately provocative, it's not because somebody whipped out a
clown
with a camera and a donkey and some jello," Sarah Wendell said.
Roberts's
characters are less repressed now, but their forwardness can seem as
artificial
as their modesty used to. "I m thinking of the movie as a vehicle for
popcorn and necking," Ford Sawyer says, in “Tribute," by way of
asking Cilia McGowan on a date. At their best, Roberts's sex scenes
contain
some of her most imaginative, least workmanlike writing. In "The Pagan
Stone," she writes, 'They lay flat on their backs, side by side on the
bed. He felt as if he'd been kicked off a cliff, doing the tumble down
through
screaming air to land in a hot river."
Toward the
end of the signing at Turn the Page, a woman approached Roberts. "This
is
for my twenty-year-old son, who is a major fan," she said, clutching a
copy of a J. D. Robb book. "But he skips all the sex scenes. So I would
like you to sign it, 'Chris: Read the sex scenes! Nora Roberts.'''
Roberts
picked up her pen and asked, "Should I write, 'Your wife would
appreciate
it'?" •
NEWYORKER.COM
Lauren
Collins talks about Nora Roberts.
|